apcmag.com june 06 apc labs
62
apc labs june 06 apcmag.com
63
softwaresoftware
2006
JUNEDETAILED PRODUCT REVIEWS AND COMPARISONS
REVIEWS
/
BEST BUYS
/
LABS CHALLENGE
labs
apcmag.com june 06 apc labs
62
apc labs june 06 apcmag.com
63
softwaresoftware
2006
JUNEDETAILED PRODUCT REVIEWS AND COMPARISONS
REVIEWS
/
BEST BUYS
/
LABS CHALLENGE
labs
AVERAGE SPEED
LevelOne WBR-3407A (v2)
Zyxel Prestige 2602HWL-61C
Zyxel Prestige 660HW
Siemens Speedstream 6520
4.89
3.94
5.12
6.06
8.55
Belkin F1PI241EGau
NetComm NB9W
Billion BIPAC7404VGP
DrayTek Vigor2800VG
Dynalink RTA1046VW
Linksys WAG54GP2
D-LINK DVA-G3340S
12.21
12.81
12.76
10.32
13.90
12.03
14.97
15.13
Billion 7300G
Thomson Speedtouch ST780WL
9.49
10.21
OPEN Networks iConnectAccess624W
Cisco 877W
0
MODEL
16
These results are the average of the 1km and 3.5km tests, to give an
indication of which modems perform best over common line-lengths.
Billion is the clear speed winner here.
This graph averages the speeds achieved by each modem across all three
test locations. Dynalink’s high-end all-in-one unit takes out the speed
crown for average throughput across all three distances: a very impressive
result. Draytek Vigor2800’s result is also stellar — it’s just a shame that its
ADSL2+ performance was so lousy.
AVERAGE WIRELESS SPEED
AVERAGE ADSL2+ SPEED
1km (LOW SNR, NO INTERLEAVE)
0
MODEL
20
Zyxel Prestige 2602HWL-61C
15.91
Thomson Speedtouch ST780WL
16.06
10.50
Zyxel Prestige 660HW
NetComm NB5Plus4
17.25
OPEN Networks iConnectAccess624W
18.4 1
Linksys WAG54GP2
17.81
OPEN Networks iConnectAccess624
18.62
Linksys AG241
17.25
LevelOne WBR-3407A (v2)
15.17
15.91
NETGEAR DG834
18.20
NetComm NB9W
11.95
Thomson Speedtouch ST546
18.20
Siemens Speedstream 6520
Cisco 877W
19.05
Dynalink RTA1046VW
18.62
Billion BIPAC7404VGP
17.62
DrayTek Vigor2800VG
11.07
Billion BIPAC7300G
15.91
Belkin F1PI241EGau
17.43
17.25
D-LINK DVA-G3340S
17.25
D-LINK DSL-504T
16.22
LevelOne FBR-1416A (v2)
16.06
Dynalink RTA1335
If you live 1km from a phone exchange and have a very good quality line,
these are the sorts of results you could get. We got these results by
shaving signal-to-noise ratio right back and turning off interleaving
altogether. Note the Cisco’s dramatic improvement in performance,
soaring from 12.6Mbit/s (with interleaving on) to 19.05Mbit/s (with it
switched off).
ADSL2+ UNDER OPTIMAL CONDITIONS
AVERAGE OF 1 & 3.5km
0
MODEL
12
Zyxel Prestige 2602HWL-61C
10.01
Thomson Speedtouch ST780WL
10.10
10.40
Zyxel Prestige 660HW
NetComm NB5Plus4
10.44
OPEN Networks iConnectAccess624W
10.84
Linksys WAG54GP2
10.56
OPEN Networks iConnectAccess624
10.57
Linksys AG241
10.25
LevelOne WBR-3407A (v2)
8.69
9.99
NETGEAR DG834
10.52
NetComm NB9W
8.55
Thomson Speedtouch ST546
10.97
Siemens Speedstream 6520
Cisco 877W
10.57
Dynalink RTA1046VW
10.48
Billion BIPAC7404VGP
11.36
DrayTek Vigor2800VG
7.61
Billion BIPAC7300G
11.84
Belkin F1PI241EGau
10.73
10.25
D-LINK DVA-G3340S
10.46
D-LINK DSL-504T
9.85
LevelOne FBR-1416A (v2)
9.41
Dynalink RTA1335
(12 pages)
(150 pages)
Manymanuals.com
Manymanuals.de
Manymanuals.fr
Manymanuals.it
Manymanuals.pl
Manymanuals.cz
Manymanuals.es
Manymanuals-pt.com
Comments to this Manuals